Grab a Slice at the Best Pizza Places on Sanibel Island!

Whether you’ve spent your mornings doing yoga on the beach, visiting Lighthouse Beach Park, or other things to do near Sanibel and Captiva Islands, you’ve probably worked up an appetite. There is certainly an appeal in going to upscale establishments while on vacation, but some nights, it’s preferable to spend some leisure time with your group without leaving your Sanibel Island rentals. No other classic family-style meal is as famous and well-loved as pizza! It’s a staple at home and away, guaranteeing a bite to eat that is familiar and delicious.

The next time you find yourself on a trip in the area, look out for these restaurants and chow down on some of the best pizza on Sanibel Island.

Great White Grill

The Great White Grill is a casual restaurant with several options for hearty, tasty meals. They were voted best lunch, best beer selection, and best place to watch the game on Sanibel Island, so their reputation certainly precedes them. If you want to get in on some local hype and find an excuse to leave your Sanibel Island condo rentals, an evening watching the game at Great White Grill is a great idea. This is an excellent choice if you want to taste some local beer, as they have 31 beers on tap, including an extensive local craft selection!

If you happen to be a Yinzer, a visit to Great White Grill might become one of your favorite things to do in Sanibel Island. Though the restaurant is in Florida, Great White Grill isn’t afraid to sport their black and yellow in support of their favorite team, the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Dante’s Coal Fired Pizza

Dante’s is worth a visit if you’re looking for a more sophisticated take on pizza. Their selection of pizzas, which range from traditional to more fanciful toppings, are all coal fried and smoked with utmost care. Alongside pizza, they offer a variety of other dishes, so there’s certain to be something for everyone in your party. You can also stop into Dante’s attached Tiki Bar for a tropical cocktail to complement your meal to add to your list of Sanibel Island things to do. The pizza portions here are impressive, so if you can’t finish it all, don’t hesitate to take the rest back home to your Sanibel Island vacation rental.

Captiva Island Pizza

If you want to try the eatery that claims to have the best pizza around Sanibel Island, you should look no further than Captiva Island Pizza. This iconic spot has a reputation for quality ingredients, speedy service, and free delivery to any location on the island, including your Captiva vacation rentals.

This restaurant was also one of the first to re-open after Hurricane Ian, which is impressive proof of its resilience! Sticking to what they’re best at, their menu consists of very little aside from their selection of delicious pizzas; their range of pizza types and ingredients is a feat in and of itself!

Island Pizza Company

Family-owned, Island Pizza Company is a restaurant that has been around for over thirty years. It’s great for those who want to eat in, take out, or even get delivery to their Captiva Island vacation rental. Alongside its impressive list of specialty pizzas, Island Pizza Company has a list of pasta entrees that rivals even its pizza selection. They also have a range of appetizers and salads, so you’ll be sure to leave full and satisfied.

Among other things, Island Pizza Company is known for its interesting flavor combinations that still stay true to its Italian-inspired cuisine. Their meals are made fresh daily, and it’s easy to distinguish their quality ingredients. There are plenty of choices for those looking for quality restaurants near Sanibel Island, and Island Pizza Company is a unique and satisfying option.

Where to Stay

Bring your pizza or leftovers back to your David L. Schuldenfrei vacation rental to relax after a day of beach fun and adventures. You can rely on us to have the perfect rental for your island getaway, so call us today to start planning your next trip to Sanibel and Captiva Island!