Enjoy The Best Sushi Restaurants Near Sanibel and Captiva Island

Known for being more than just a boating paradise, if you are taking a trip to Sanibel and Captiva Island, it is probably a good idea to start planning your meals ahead of time. After all, the amount of sushi near Sanibel Island and Captiva Island makes for practically limitless options! Whether you’re searching for a bite that’s perfect for a casual night out or seeking a special spot to have the island feast of your dreams, this list is certain to include the exact restaurant you’re looking for when staying in one of our Captiva vacation rentals. 

Two sushi rolls displayed on a stone platter.
Photo from Shutterstock

Shima Japanese Steakhouse

If you’re looking for a tasty place to eat during a stay in your Sanibel Island rental, take a stroll over to the restaurant that was voted best sushi, best steak, and best chef on Sanibel and Captiva Islands. Shima Japanese Steakhouse is located within Sundial Beach Resort and Spa and has an unbeatable atmosphere that practically oozes class and sophistication. 

The steakhouse prides itself on its ability to provide an authentic experience and is famous for the incredible arrangements and aromas of its cuisine. The skill of the restaurant’s hibachi chef truly gives guests both dinner and a show, which is no surprise considering Shima’s various awards.

Sakura Chinatown

If you’re craving a meal that’s fresh and created from the area’s finest ingredients, Sakura Chinatown is certain to satiate your hunger. Their impressive array of both Chinese and Japanese specialties is crafted with love, and the combination of these two Asian cuisines gives way to an expansive menu that is packed full of options.

Sakura Chinatown is a recommended option for travelers on a budget, as its menu might be broad, but it is also quite affordable. Not to mention, the restaurant’s website has a section dedicated to coupons, which is an extra push of encouragement that makes the meals very hard to turn down.

If you’d like to relax in a dim, comfortable environment, eat in and enjoy the restaurant’s newly renovated dining room. But, for those nights that you just can’t justify getting up and leaving your Captiva vacation rentals, rest assured — Sakura Chinatown offers delivery to the majority of the island. Knowing that delicious sushi is just a phone call away, this unique local eatery is one that you simply can’t justify not trying.

When looking for ways to experience Sanibel and Captiva Island on a budget, you can’t go wrong here!

Plan Your Trip Today!

Enjoy the finest sushi Sanibel and Captiva Island have to offer. Book your stay with us at Schuldenfrei Rentals and experience all this area offers!


Many restaurants can cultivate a feeling of authenticity. However, there are far fewer that can combine authenticity with modernity in a way that feels so natural. LYNQ is one of those establishments, and it’s clear that they have a strength in marrying food that satisfies with a setting that entertains. 

The structure of the restaurant certainly stands out among similar eateries; club-style lighting and music, gorgeous chandeliers, and cozy umbrella-clad cabanas set a precedent that LYNQ is classy and comfortable. The menu is an intentional fusion between a variety of popular global cuisines, one, of course, being Asian. Other options include American, French, Italian, and Mexican food, as well as multiple fusions and combinations of these flavors.

The company describes itself as forward-thinking and emphasizes its desire to bring people together using the power of cuisine. Their menu includes daily specials that combine unlikely flavor profiles that are meant to inspire and promote excitement in eating. Visit LYNQ to discover one of the most unique Sanibel Island things to do.

Blu Sushi

Blu Sushi, aside from its impeccable menu of delicious sushi, has the added advantage of being one of the most pre-established sushi eateries in South Florida. According to their website, the restaurant was established in 2002 after its owners decided that the sushi experience in the area was too limited. They had a vision with Blu to create an environment where people of all ages, classes, and cultures could unite and appreciate the art that is sushi.

Over the years, Blu has evolved into a top sushi establishment in the area, bringing its goals to fruition with its quality performance and impressive flavors. Along with its exhaustive list of sushi, from standard rolls to exclusive specialties, the restaurant also has an all-you-can-eat lunch option for those who don’t think a single roll could satisfy.

Blu sees sushi as a form of artistry, and that’s clear with every bite. Come for the food, stay for the experience, and don’t forget to try a few of their signature cocktails while you’re at it! If its reputation proves correct, you’ll be raving about the time you’ve had the whole trip back to your Captiva Island condo rental.

Ninja Thai

Because many of the eateries on this list specialize in Chinese and Japanese cuisine, Ninja Thai and Sushi Bar stands out in its ability to deliver an authentic take on Thai cuisine in South Florida. If you’re hankering for traditional Thai food while on your trip, taking a trip to Ninja Thai is going to be one of the best things to do on Sanibel Island. Ninja Thai specializes in friendly, reliable service that will leave a smile on your face before you even start to have your meal.


Yellowfin Sushi and Sake Bar is an amazing option for those who want casual service with exceptional food. Yellowfin is a perfect choice for guests who want to take the time to sit in an authentic environment to enjoy their meal or those who want to quickly order online and take their meal back to their Sanibel Island condo rentals. Much like their menu is an Asian fusion, their service is a fusion between immediacy and care.

Something that sets Yellowfin apart is its impressive, wide selection of sake and other Asian beverages. They also have a list of Japanese rice beers, as well as some domestic craft brews and wines.

Whether you want a teapot of hot sake or an ice-cold glass of apple or coconut sake, they can get you the drink you desire most.

Ichi Yummy

Ichi Yummy is a sushi and hibachi restaurant that is perfect for a rainy day. There are times during a trip when you want quality food without the hassle that can sometimes be going to a restaurant. With its options easily available through call, online order, and Doordash, you can enjoy your authentic cuisine without having to step food out of your Sanibel vacation rental. Convenience doesn’t always have to come at the cost of quality, and Ichi Yummy is living proof.

Yummy Yummy

Yummy Yummy is a restaurant that certainly lives up to its name, often boasting itself as having the best sushi near Captiva Island. To determine that verdict, you’ll have to try for yourself, but the restaurant’s reputation for high-quality ingredients at affordable prices is a great sign that you won’t find yourself disappointed.

Sushi is the specialty at Yummy Yummy, and its menu centers on that food item the most. There’s a star to every show, and at Yummy Yummy, you just can’t go wrong with any of their rolls. Next time you’re in the area, take a stop and experience their friendly atmosphere and winning service, then decide for yourself if you think they truly have the best sushi near Sanibel Island.