Which Sanibel or Captiva Island Condo is Right for Your Second Home?

Are you thinking about purchasing a second home? Congrats! Buying a second home can be
an exciting prospect.

Before you can choose a property, you’ve got to pick a destination! Sanibel and Captiva Islands are both incredible destinations for a second home, and we’re proud to offer tons of luxurious Sanibel real estate for you to choose from. So, which of our Sanibel Island condos for sale is right for you? Read on to find out!

walk way to beach surrounded by green bushes and palms

Real Estate in Sanibel Island

There’s truly no more picturesque destination than Sanibel Island, with its stunning white-sand beaches and crystal-clear waters. Sanibel Island has even been named as one of the Top 10 Florida Beach Towns by USA Today! When you choose to purchase real estate in Sanibel Island, you’ll never be more than a few moments away from gorgeous sands and incredible shelling opportunities, making for a perfect relaxing activity or a great way to watch the sunset. 

On top of the remarkable beaches, Sanibel Island is also full of fun activities. There are all kinds of delicious locally-owned restaurants for you to experience, as well as unique shops and boutiques to find some one-of-a-kind décor for your new home. Plus, you’re just moments away from fascinating attractions like the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum, outdoor destinations like the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge, and so many others! 

Condos for Sale in Sanibel Island

When you’re researching condos for sale in Sanibel Island, you’ll first want to consider the complex. Luckily, there are tons of luxurious Sanibel and Captiva Island condo complexes on the island, each offering something unique for its residents to enjoy. 


Atrium is a smaller community of 24 furnished units, offering 2- or 3-bedroom configurations. This complex on West Gulf Drive is located just a stone’s throw away from the island’s most popular services and attractions, and the complex itself offers amenities like a heated pool, covered parking, storage access, and a tennis court.

Captiva Shores

Captiva Shores on nearby Captiva Island also has 24 units of 2- or 3-bedrooms. This property has stunning views of both the Gulf of Mexico and Pine Island Sound, even offering boat docks! The complex also has a swimming pool for residents to enjoy. From Captiva Shores, it’s easy to reach the village center with all of its shops and restaurants.

Lighthouse Pointe

Lighthouse Pointe has 69 fully furnished units of 2- or 3-bedrooms, offering unmatched access to San Carlos Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. You’ll be able to easily access the beach, the Sanibel Lighthouse, and the “Old Town” area with some of the best Sanibel restaurants. Complex amenities include two tennis courts and a heated pool.

Sanibel Moorings

Sanibel Moorings offers 122 units with 1-, 2-, or 3-bedroom configurations. These furnished units are perfect for singles, couples, or families! The property is beautifully decorated with lush landscaping and a botanical garden. Residents have access to two swimming pools, tennis courts, and a canal with dockage for boaters. 

Loggerhead Cay

Loggerhead Cay offers 168 2-bedroom units, making it one of the biggest complexes on Sanibel Island. Its convenient location on East Gulf Drive puts this complex right near all the best shops and restaurants on the island. It offers quick access to the beaches of the Gulf of Mexico. Complex amenities include a heated pool, two tennis courts, a shuffleboard court, and a barbecue area.

Also located on East Gulf Drive is Sandalfoot, offering 60 fully furnished units of either 1 or 2 bedrooms. You’ll have a view of the Gulf in every unit! In addition to Sandalfoot’s prime location near the best entertainment on the island, this complex also offers amenities such as a heated pool, tennis courts, and shuffleboard court. 


Beachcomber is another East Gulf Drive complex, offering 20 fully furnished units of 2 bedrooms each. Every property has a luxurious lanai where you can watch the Gulf waters anytime you, please! On top of being near many of Sanibel Island’s most popular attractions, Beachcomber also offers several convenient amenities for its residents, including a heated pool and tennis courts. 

Mariner Point

At Mariner Point on Sanibel Island, you’ll find 100 units ranging from 1 to 3 bedrooms each. This condo complex is situated right on the San Carlos Bay, giving you absolutely stunning views of the sunrise over the water, and you might even be lucky enough to spot dolphins from your window! This complex is on the east side of the island within close distance to shops and restaurants. At the complex, you’ll have two heated pools, two tennis courts, a fishing pier and boatage dock, and barbecue grills.

aerial view of sanibel island real estate and beach view

The Sanddollar Condominiums

The Sanddollar Condominiums complex is a smaller community, offering 36 units of 2 or 3 bedrooms each. This complex is located on Middle Gulf Drive, allowing residents to reach any attraction on the island with a short drive or bike ride. You’ll be steps away from the beach and will also enjoy complex amenities like a heated pool, 3 tennis courts, and a barbecue grill.

Sanibel Arms West

Finally, Sanibel Arms West is a very conveniently located community situated on East Gulf Drive. This complex has 104 units of 2 bedrooms each. You’ll have easy access to the Gulf of Mexico as well as a canal where you can dock your boat. Other complex amenities include multiple tennis courts and a heated pool.

Consider Your Condo as an Income Source When You Are Not There

It’s always nice to have a luxurious second home where you can escape the worries of everyday life and enjoy the gorgeous weather in Sanibel, regardless of the season. After all, many people purchase Sanibel Island real estate to have a winter escape or a guaranteed place to stay when they head down to Florida for the summer! It’s no secret that purchasing real estate down here in Sanibel Island can be a sound investment, but what about the times when you’re not staying here?

Many people hold back from purchasing a second home because they don’t like the idea of their property sitting vacant for the majority of the year while they’re away. Well, it doesn’t have to! Your second home can actually serve as a great source of income when you’re not using it! By renting out your second home as a vacation property, you’ll be able to provide visitors to Sanibel Island with a safe and luxurious place to stay, all while making some extra money for you to spend the next time you come down here! It’s truly a win-win situation.

view of ocean and palm trees

We know that you have a ton of options in selecting the location for your second home. Still, we hope this guide is a valuable resource for your buying journey. If you want to know even more about all the hottest Sanibel Island real estate and are ready to jump in with your purchase, contact us today! David Schuldenfrei and his team would be happy to help you find your ultimate second home.